Driver fatigue and your fleet: the risk assessment DVSA expects and most operators haven't written
DVSA asked for our fatigue policy at a traffic examiner visit in 2022. We had a drivers' hours policy. Not the same thing. Here's what a fatigue risk assessment actually needs to cover.

I had a DVSA traffic examiner on site in February 2022. Unannounced. The kind of visit where you learn very quickly which documents you have and which ones you think you have.
She asked for our fatigue management policy. I pointed her at the drivers' hours folder — our infringement procedure, our tachograph download schedule, the working time records. She thanked me for those and asked again for the fatigue management policy. We went around this twice before I understood she was asking for something else entirely. Something we didn't have.
A drivers' hours compliance document tells you how you manage the rules. A fatigue risk assessment tells you how you identify and manage the risk of fatigue itself — the operational factors that push drivers toward tiredness, and what you do about them. They're related but they're not the same document.
Why fatigue is a legal obligation, not just a management preference
The Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 places a general duty on employers to ensure the health, safety and welfare of employees so far as is reasonably practicable. That duty applies to the risk of fatigue just as it applies to the risk of manual handling injury or chemical exposure.
HSE has been clear since at least 2006 that driving while fatigued is a foreseeable workplace risk, and that employers who put drivers on the road in conditions that predictably lead to fatigue — insufficient sleep opportunity, routes that peak in the early hours of the morning, patterns that consistently push against working time limits — are failing to meet that duty.
The Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999 require employers to make a suitable and sufficient assessment of the risks to employees. For a fleet operator whose employees drive HGVs, the risk assessment must include the fatigue risk. That's not optional.
DVSA's Earned Recognition scheme and its standard audit expectations both include fatigue management as an element of driver risk. Operators without a documented fatigue policy are more likely to face adverse OCRS outcomes following a traffic examiner visit. It's not that DVSA can revoke your licence for not having a fatigue policy — it's that the absence of one is consistent with the kind of management failures that lead to other problems, and examiners note it.
What a fatigue risk assessment actually covers
A fatigue risk assessment isn't a one-paragraph statement that fatigue is dangerous and drivers should get enough sleep. It's an assessment of the specific operational factors in your fleet that create fatigue risk, and the controls you have in place for each.
The factors you need to assess include:
- Shift patterns and timing. Early starts before 6am, night shifts, split shifts, and variable start times all increase fatigue risk. If your drivers are regularly starting at 4am or driving overnight, your assessment needs to acknowledge this and document what you do about it — minimum rest guarantees, no consecutive overnight shifts without adequate recovery, and so on.
- Journey length and driving time. Long-distance driving without adequate break patterns creates accumulating fatigue even when drivers are technically within their hours. The 4.5-hour limit for EU hours is a legal minimum, not an endorsement of continuous driving to that limit as a routine practice.
- Route characteristics. Monotonous motorway driving, particularly at night, increases fatigue risk relative to the same duration in varied conditions. If you run regular overnight A1 runs from Edinburgh to London, that's a different fatigue profile from daytime distribution work in a city.
- Home rest adequacy. Your drivers' hours comply with the regulation. But are your drivers actually getting adequate sleep? The working time regulations set limits on hours of work. They don't guarantee sleep quality. A driver who works nights and sleeps poorly through the day because of domestic circumstances is arriving for shift with a fatigue load you can't see in the tachograph.
- Consecutive days worked. Even within legal weekly hours, consecutive days of early starts or long shifts accumulate fatigue. Shift scheduling that gives drivers at least one full rest day per week — not just meeting the weekly rest requirement, but actually allowing recovery — is part of fatigue risk management.
Controls your assessment should document
The risk assessment identifies the risks. The controls document what you do about them. Standard controls I'd expect to see in a documented fatigue management system for an HGV fleet:
A pre-journey check procedure — drivers confirming at the start of shift that they're fit for work, including adequate rest in the preceding period. Not just a signature on a form, but a conversation that the manager has the authority and expectation to act on if a driver reports being tired. If a driver tells you they've had four hours of sleep and you put them in the cab anyway, your risk assessment controls aren't working.
A route planning standard that factors in journey timing. If a driver's ETA calculation puts them arriving at a destination at 3am — statistically one of the highest fatigue-risk periods — your route plan should flag that and either build in additional breaks or consider whether the journey can start later.
A reporting mechanism for drivers to flag fatigue concerns without fear of consequence. If a driver who raises a concern about their fatigue gets taken off a lucrative run as a result, word gets round fast. The practical result is that drivers stop telling you when they're tired.
A monitoring approach — using tachograph analysis to identify drivers who consistently push toward their hours limits, who take breaks late, or who have patterns suggesting they're managing fatigue badly. Tachograph data isn't just a compliance record; it's a fatigue indicator if you look at it that way.
The short-haul fleet isn't exempt
Operators running domestic routes or shorter-range distribution work sometimes assume that fatigue policy is mainly an HGV long-haul concern. It isn't. Fatigue in an urban distribution context — multiple drops, time pressure, parking stress — is a different kind of fatigue from motorway monotony, but it's still real and it still needs to be assessed.
Domestic drivers who aren't subject to EU drivers' hours — running on GB domestic rules under the Transport Act 1968 — still have a fatigue risk. The 10-hour daily driving limit under domestic rules doesn't make fatigue less of an issue than the 9-hour EU daily limit. Your fatigue risk assessment needs to cover all drivers, not just those running under tachograph rules.
Documenting and reviewing
The assessment needs to be written down. Not in your head. Not in a training session you ran four years ago that nobody can produce the notes from. Written, dated, signed by someone with management authority, and reviewed at reasonable intervals — at minimum annually, and any time there's a significant change in how you operate. New contracts, new shift patterns, new routes — review the fatigue assessment.
When the traffic examiner asked for our fatigue policy in 2022, I had nothing to give her. What I had instead was a narrative — I explained how we managed shifts, how we briefed drivers on rest, what we did when a driver called in tired. She recorded it. And then she gave us a recommendation to formalise it.
We now have a documented fatigue risk assessment that covers the specific routes and shift patterns we run, the controls in place for each identified risk, and a review date. It's six pages. It took an afternoon to write. Getting into the habit of doing this properly is significantly easier than explaining to a TC why your driver fell asleep at the wheel and you had no documented fatigue management in place.