Back to blog
Operations10 June 20266 min read

Fleet insurance renewal: the questions your broker hopes you won't ask

My last renewal came in 23% higher despite a clean claims year. I pushed back on three things. Got 11% off. Here's what I actually asked.

Fleet insurance renewal: the questions your broker hopes you won't ask

23% up on a clean year

That's what my last fleet renewal quote came in at. No claims. Better OCRS than the previous year. Fleet management system in place. And the premium had gone up by almost a quarter.

My broker's explanation: "market hardening," "reinsurance costs," "the general commercial fleet environment." I've been in transport for fifteen years. I know what vague sounds like when it's covering for something. So I started asking questions.

Three specific questions. By the time I'd finished asking them, the renewal came down 11%. Not magic. Not confrontation. Just knowing what to ask and why the answer matters.

How fleet insurance is actually priced

Your broker submits your renewal to underwriters. The underwriter's model takes in your fleet size, vehicle types, driver ages, claims history (usually five years), operating territory, and a handful of other factors. They apply a rate per vehicle or a blended fleet rate, add their loading for profit and risk, and that's your premium.

The broker typically works on commission from the underwriter — calculated as a percentage of the premium. Which means a higher premium means a higher payout for the broker. I'm not suggesting brokers are dishonest. Most aren't. But the incentive structure is worth understanding. Your broker has a financial interest in the renewal going through. They do not have a financial interest in it going through at the lowest possible number.

Question 1: Can I see the loss ratio?

The loss ratio is claims paid out divided by premiums received. If the underwriter paid out £8,000 in claims on a fleet that paid £20,000 in premiums, the loss ratio is 40%. That's a very profitable account for the underwriter.

A lot of underwriters won't share loss ratios directly with the insured — they'll share them with the broker. Ask your broker to get the actual loss ratio for your account. Not an estimate. The number.

If your loss ratio is below 60%, you're a profitable account. Below 40% and you have real leverage in negotiation. The underwriter wants to keep you. They're making money on you. A 5-10% reduction in premium to retain a profitable account is entirely rational from their side.

If your loss ratio is over 100% — you've cost more than you've paid — that's a harder conversation. But at least you know what you're dealing with rather than arguing about "market conditions."

Question 2: What's the commission rate?

Ask your broker what commission percentage they receive on this policy. They're required to disclose this under the Insurance Distribution Directive if you ask. Some will volunteer it. Many won't mention it unless pressed.

Commission rates on commercial fleet policies vary widely. I've seen everything from 8% to 22%. On a £40,000 fleet premium, that's the difference between the broker earning £3,200 and £8,800. For the same piece of work.

Knowing the commission rate doesn't mean demanding the broker works for less. It means you can assess whether they're genuinely shopping the market or just renewing with the incumbent underwriter because it's the path of least resistance. There's a difference.

Question 3: Have you marketed this to at least three underwriters?

A broker who isn't marketing your renewal competitively isn't earning their commission. Ask them to confirm they've approached at least three underwriters with the full risk information — not just the incumbent.

On my last renewal, the broker had approached two: the incumbent and one alternative. The alternative came back higher. This was presented to me as "we've shopped around and the current insurer is competitive." What they hadn't done was approach two Lloyd's syndicates who specialise in commercial fleet and who I subsequently found had significantly lower headline rates for clean accounts.

I didn't switch underwriters in the end. But the Lloyd's quotes were useful leverage, and the incumbent dropped their renewal by 11% rather than risk losing the account.

Telematics and insurance: the relationship is less simple than brokers claim

Every broker will tell you that telematics reduces your premium. Some are right. The impact depends entirely on what you do with the data, and whether the underwriter actually has access to it.

There are two models. Some insurers integrate directly with telematics providers — they get driving scores fed into their model and reduce the premium based on actual driver behaviour. These are usually specialist fleet insurers or specific telematics-linked policies.

Most commercial fleet policies don't integrate with your telematics. Your broker tells the underwriter you have telematics installed, which gives you a small loading reduction — maybe 3-5% — for demonstrating risk management intent. Whether your drivers are actually driving well is irrelevant to the premium calculation.

I use telematics data for driver management, not primarily for insurance. But if you're on a policy that does genuinely integrate with your telematics, make sure the underwriter is actually pulling the data. If they're not, you're paying for hardware and connectivity without getting the insurance benefit.

Named driver versus any driver

On a fleet of under 20 vehicles, you might be on an any-driver policy — any authorised driver can use any vehicle. Above 20 vehicles or so, underwriters typically want named driver lists.

Named driver policies are usually cheaper per vehicle, because the underwriter knows exactly who's driving what. But they carry administrative burden: every driver change requires a policy update, and if a driver who isn't on the policy gets behind the wheel, you have a coverage problem.

For fleets with high driver turnover, any-driver can be worth the premium uplift. For stable fleets where the same ten drivers have driven the same routes for three years, named driver almost always saves money. And on most policies, you can set a named-driver minimum age — say, 25 — to exclude the most expensive demographic from driving your high-value vehicles.

What I check before every renewal

First: claims history accuracy. Get the full claims register from the broker and check every entry. Claims that were reported but not paid out still affect the loss ratio. Make sure they're coded correctly.

Second: vehicle list accuracy. Uninsured vehicles on a fleet policy are a significant problem. So are vehicles that have been disposed of but are still on the schedule — you're paying premium for something you no longer own.

Third: territory. If your fleet has expanded its operating area since last year and you haven't told your insurer, you may have a coverage gap for incidents outside the declared territory.

Excess structure: the lever most operators ignore

The voluntary excess on most commercial fleet policies is negotiable. Most brokers default to the minimum — usually £500 or £1,000 per claim. Raising it to £2,500 or £5,000 can reduce the annual premium substantially, because you're taking on more of the small-claim risk yourself.

Whether that's sensible depends on your cash flow and your claims frequency. If you're averaging two claims per year and both are under £2,000, a high excess might cost you more than it saves. But if your claims are rare and large — a single major incident every three to four years — a higher excess almost always pays back.

Run the numbers on your last five years of claims before the renewal conversation. Not a guess. The actual numbers. Then decide on your excess position from evidence, not from whatever your broker suggests as the default.

One more thing

Ask your broker to provide a summary of the market they approached and the quotes they received, in writing, before you sign the renewal. Not a verbal summary. A written record. That document is what tells you, at the next renewal, whether they're actually working for you or just renewing with the incumbent every year and taking their commission.

Most brokers will do it without complaint. The ones who push back on that request are telling you something useful about how they operate.

Fleet InsuranceInsurancerenewalbrokerOperationscost-management

Run a fleet that has to keep DVSA happy?

FleetPad replaces walkaround paperwork, defect logs, and PMI records with one system the transport manager actually reads.