Back to blog
Operations23 June 20266 min read

Grey fleet vehicles: the employer duty of care that most transport managers think is HR's problem

One of my sales reps drove 200 miles for a client meeting in a car with six months of MoT on the clock. I found out three weeks after the meeting. That's when I overhauled our grey fleet procedure.

Grey fleet vehicles: the employer duty of care that most transport managers think is HR's problem

It's your problem, not HR's

I've heard it enough times to find it frustrating: "Grey fleet? That's an HR thing." It isn't. The moment one of your employees gets into their own car to make a journey for work purposes — a client visit, a site inspection, a delivery in a pinch — health and safety law applies to that journey in the same way it applies to everything else your company does. The Health and Safety at Work Act 1974. The Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999. Both apply. Both put obligations on you as an employer, regardless of who owns the vehicle.

The HSE is unambiguous on this. "Health and safety law applies to work activities on the road in the same way as it does on a fixed site." That includes your sales rep's seven-year-old hatchback, your service engineer's van that she bought privately, and the manager who drives his personal car to training days twice a month.

What grey fleet actually means

Grey fleet means employees using their own vehicles for business journeys — not commuting to a regular workplace, which isn't covered. Once the journey is for business purposes, you're in scope. Cash-allowance drivers are in scope too. The vehicle not being yours doesn't reduce your duty of care; it just means you're relying on someone else to keep it in a safe condition, without the procurement and maintenance controls you'd normally have over a company vehicle.

That's the core problem. On a company vehicle, you control the PMI schedule, the tyre checks, the annual test, the roadworthiness. On a grey fleet car, you're depending on an employee who might prioritise other things. And if that car is involved in a collision during a business journey, the investigation will ask what steps you took to verify its condition.

The three-part risk assessment

HSE guidance on managing driving at work structures the risk assessment around three areas: the journey, the driver, and the vehicle. For grey fleet, all three need specific attention.

The journey. Is this a journey that should be made at all, or can it be handled by public transport, video call, or a company vehicle instead? What's the route? What time of day? Is the driver under time pressure? Journey risk is manageable — but only if you've thought about it in advance, not at the moment someone's already in the car.

The driver. Does the employee hold a valid driving licence for the vehicle they're using? When did you last check? Licence-checking obligations exist for company vehicle drivers — most operators have a process for those. Grey fleet drivers often aren't included in the same check cycle. They should be. A standard DVLA licence check through a proper consent-based process covers grey fleet drivers just as it covers fleet drivers.

The vehicle. This is the uncomfortable one. An employee's personal car is theirs. You can't walk around it the way you would a company vehicle. What you can do — and what HSE guidance supports — is require employees to confirm, as a condition of being reimbursed for business mileage, that their vehicle is roadworthy, holds a valid MoT certificate, is insured for business use, and is taxed. That confirmation needs to be in writing and renewed at least annually.

The business use insurance gap

Here's the one that catches people out most regularly. Standard personal motor insurance typically covers social, domestic and pleasure (SDP) use. Commuting to a regular workplace (SDP+C). Business use — driving during working hours for work purposes — is a separate class and needs to be specifically included in the policy.

Most people don't check. They assume that if they have comprehensive insurance, they're covered for everything. They aren't. A driver involved in a collision during a business journey, with only SDP cover, can find themselves uninsured. That exposure falls on them — and potentially on you, if the third party pursues your company as the employer.

Your grey fleet declaration should require employees to confirm they hold business use cover. The class of use matters: "business use class 1" typically covers the employee driving for their employer; "class 2" adds a named spouse; "class 3" covers a car used to carry samples or goods. Most grey fleet business journeys need class 1 at minimum. Make it explicit.

MoT and servicing

A valid MoT certificate means the vehicle passed a basic safety check on a specific date. It says nothing about condition since that date. But it's the minimum bar, and not having one is a clear indicator that the vehicle hasn't met even that standard.

Requiring employees to produce a copy of their MoT certificate — or allowing you to check via the GOV.UK MoT history tool, which only needs a registration number — as part of the grey fleet declaration is straightforward. If a certificate has lapsed, the employee can't make business journeys in that vehicle until it's renewed. Full stop.

Beyond MoT, you should ask employees to confirm that the vehicle is serviced in line with the manufacturer's schedule and that they're not aware of any outstanding defects. This doesn't mean you're responsible for the service — you're not. It means you've asked the question and the employee has confirmed the position. That record matters if something goes wrong.

What your declaration should cover

I use a one-page grey fleet vehicle declaration that employees sign at induction and renew annually. It covers:

  • Vehicle registration, make, model and year
  • Confirmation of a valid MoT (copy or GOV.UK check date noted)
  • Confirmation of valid road tax (VED)
  • Confirmation of valid motor insurance including business use (copy of certificate of insurance required)
  • Confirmation no outstanding defects affecting roadworthiness
  • Confirmation serviced in line with manufacturer's guidance
  • Confirmation the employee holds a valid driving licence appropriate for the vehicle

Keep these on file. I keep them alongside the licence check records — same system, same renewal cycle. The whole process takes about ten minutes per employee per year once you've got the form right.

Mileage reimbursement as the control point

The cleanest enforcement mechanism is this: no completed grey fleet declaration, no mileage reimbursement. HMRC's approved mileage allowance payment (AMAP) rates — currently 45p per mile for the first 10,000 business miles in a car, 25p above that — are the standard reimbursement basis. Tie the reimbursement to the declaration and you've got a natural annual renewal trigger built into the process.

Employees who don't want to submit the declaration either stop making grey fleet journeys (which is fine) or bring the issue to the surface so you can discuss alternatives. It's a useful forcing function.

The journey approval step

For higher-risk journeys — anything over three hours, early-morning or late-night runs, journeys in difficult weather — consider a basic approval step. Not bureaucratic sign-off for every 20-minute drive, but a simple check that someone in management has considered the journey before it happens. "Are you okay to do this today? What time are you leaving? Is there a rest stop planned?"

Most road fatalities involving workers happen because fatigue and time pressure aren't managed before the journey starts. Once someone's on the motorway, it's too late. The HSE's driving for work guidance makes exactly this point — journey planning and management is a live employer obligation, not a one-time policy document.

Where your liability sits

If an employee is injured in a collision during a business journey, and an investigation finds you had no grey fleet policy, no vehicle checks, no licence validation, and no journey management — that's a serious position. Under the Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007, as well as the HSWA and the Management Regs, the company's exposure is real and the personal liability of directors and senior managers is too.

I'm not trying to alarm anyone. Most grey fleet journeys are uneventful and the risks are manageable. But "manageable" requires you to actually manage them. The paperwork is genuinely light once you've set it up. A declaration form, an annual renewal, a licence check cycle. If you're already doing that for company vehicle drivers and the grey fleet has slipped out of the process, fix it this week. The liability gap it closes is significant and the effort to close it is small.

Grey FleethswaEmployer DutyRisk ManagementDriver Management

Run a fleet that has to keep DVSA happy?

FleetPad replaces walkaround paperwork, defect logs, and PMI records with one system the transport manager actually reads.