Back to blog
Compliance6 November 20266 min read

Transport manager personal prosecution: how HSWA section 37 puts you in the dock alongside the company

The company pays the fine. But Section 37 of the Health and Safety at Work Act puts the TM in court personally when the company's offence was down to their neglect. I looked up what that means.

Transport manager personal prosecution: how HSWA section 37 puts you in the dock alongside the company

The company gets prosecuted. But you might too.

When a fleet is involved in a serious incident — a fatality, a major accident investigation, a DVSA prosecution for systematic non-compliance — the operator company is usually the defendant. The company pays the fine, receives the prosecution, has its O-licence reviewed.

But Section 37(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 creates a separate and parallel route to personal criminal liability for transport managers and directors. Not as the company's representatives — as individuals in their own right. And 'I didn't know about it' is not a complete defence.

What section 37 actually says

I went and read it. The relevant part says that where an offence under the Act is committed by a body corporate, and the offence was committed 'with the consent or connivance of, or to have been attributable to any neglect on the part of, any director, manager, secretary or other similar officer,' that officer is guilty of the offence personally and liable to be proceeded against and punished.

Three routes to personal liability: consent, connivance, or neglect.

Consent means you knew about it and approved. Connivance means you knew about it and didn't stop it when you could. Neglect means you didn't know about it, but you should have, and your failure to find out or act was culpable.

Neglect is the one that catches transport managers. Not deliberate wrongdoing — just not doing the job properly.

What 'neglect' means in practice

A transport manager who delegates all driver hours monitoring to a clerical administrator and never reviews the output has, in certain circumstances, neglected their statutory responsibilities. A TM who signs PMI sheets without reading them isn't exercising the oversight their role requires. A TM who knows that a driver's licence is under review and doesn't pause that driver from driving until the DVLA decision is made has made a decision, even if it was a decision to do nothing.

The courts have consistently held that the 'neglect' limb of Section 37 requires actual culpability — not just poor management, but a failure that falls below what an officer in that position could reasonably be expected to do. But 'reasonably expected to do' is a meaningful standard for a named transport manager. You are professionally qualified and legally responsible for the operation. Neglect is assessed against that standard, not against a lower bar.

How it connects to the O-licence

The Road Transport (Working Time) Regulations 2005, the Drivers' Hours and Tachographs regulations, and the road traffic legislation that governs roadworthiness all carry penalties that can reach the Health and Safety framework through the Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007 when a fatality is involved.

For the Corporate Manslaughter Act 2007, the offence is committed by organisations, not individuals. That Act specifically does not create individual liability for directors or managers. But Section 37 of HSWA does — for the health and safety offences that are typically investigated alongside a serious road incident. In practice, when the police or HSE investigate a fatal HGV accident, the Section 37 route is one of the tools available if there's evidence that a manager's neglect contributed.

Separately from criminal prosecution, a TM who is personally prosecuted and convicted may be found to have lost their good repute under the Road Transport (Operator Licensing) Regulations — which means the Traffic Commissioner can consider whether they should remain named on an O-licence.

What the Traffic Commissioner expects from a TM

The TC's assessment of good repute under Regulation 1071/2009 as retained in UK law includes relevant criminal convictions. A Section 37 conviction — particularly one relating to road transport safety — is directly relevant. The TC doesn't need to wait for a prosecution; the good repute assessment covers conduct generally. But a conviction is hard to manage away.

A TM who has been prosecuted personally faces a potential double consequence: criminal liability and TC referral. In serious cases, the TC can impose conditions on the O-licence or call the operator to a public inquiry specifically about the TM's fitness to continue in the role.

The documentation defence

The most practical protection against personal liability is documentation. Not as a paper trail to hide behind — a prosecution won't be deflected by documents that don't reflect reality. But genuine records of oversight genuinely exercised are the most effective way to demonstrate that you were doing your job.

What 'doing your job' looks like: signed review of tachograph analysis at least monthly, with evidence you acted on infringements. PMI records you've personally countersigned and reviewed, not just filed. Driver licence checks with dates. Signed risk assessments. A maintenance contract you've actually read and whose contractor you've held to account.

I had a conversation with another TM a few years back who kept a personal log — not a legal requirement — of every maintenance decision, every driver conversation about compliance, every time he'd overruled a commercial pressure to put a vehicle on the road before it was ready. He said it wasn't because he expected to be prosecuted. It was because it made him a better TM. He knew exactly what he'd done and when, which meant he could also identify what wasn't working and fix it.

That's the standard Section 37 implies: not perfect compliance, because systems are never perfect. But demonstrable, genuine effort to find problems and deal with them.

Agency and contractor arrangements

Some operators use an external TM on a contracted basis. The Section 37 question gets interesting here. An external TM is a contracted individual — the company they're named on has the O-licence obligation. But the external TM who signs off maintenance records, reviews tachograph analysis, and is paid to exercise oversight is functioning in a managerial role in relation to that operation.

If an incident occurs and the external TM's review was inadequate — if they signed off records they didn't properly check, or failed to flag a pattern they should have noticed — Section 37 analysis applies to them too. The contract doesn't insulate them. It may actually clarify that they had the role and the responsibility.

What changes after a serious incident

When a fleet vehicle is involved in a fatal accident, the sequence typically runs: police investigation, then DVSA involvement if drivers' hours or roadworthiness is in scope, then potentially HSE if there's an employer health and safety dimension. The three threads can run concurrently.

At the point of initial investigation, a TM who has contemporaneous records of compliance activity is in a significantly different position from one who doesn't. Not just legally — practically. You can explain what you were doing and when. You can show the maintenance schedule that was running. You can produce the tachograph analysis from the months before the incident.

The absence of those records doesn't prove neglect. But it makes it harder to prove its absence.

The point is not to frighten you

Section 37 isn't deployed routinely. Most transport managers operate for entire careers without it ever becoming relevant. But it exists, and understanding that your personal liability as a named TM is real — not absorbed by the company — changes how you think about oversight. The paperwork isn't bureaucracy. It's evidence of the job being done.

I've been a named TM on an O-licence for fifteen years. The thing that keeps me doing the monthly analysis reviews and the quarterly driver checks isn't fear of prosecution. It's that I know exactly what's happening on my fleet at any given moment, and that's what the job is. Section 37 just puts a legal label on it.

Transport Managerpersonal-liabilityhswa-1974prosecutionsection-37

Run a fleet that has to keep DVSA happy?

FleetPad replaces walkaround paperwork, defect logs, and PMI records with one system the transport manager actually reads.