Back to blog
Driver Management9 November 20267 min read

Road Transport Working Time Regulations: the 48-hour average HGV drivers can't opt out of

My HR manager drafted opt-out agreements for our HGV drivers in 2017. They were worthless. The Road Transport (Working Time) Regulations 2005 have no opt-out clause — and most operators only find this out at a DVSA visit.

Road Transport Working Time Regulations: the 48-hour average HGV drivers can't opt out of

My HR manager drafted 48-hour opt-out agreements for every driver on the fleet in 2017. Standard practice, she said — our warehouse staff had all signed one, our office team had signed one, so she'd done the same for the HGV drivers. I thanked her, filed them, and didn't think about it again.

Two years later, a DVSA Traffic Examiner sat in my office and asked to see our working time compliance records. I explained about the opt-outs. He explained that they were meaningless for professional HGV drivers. That conversation cost me three months of back-records, a formal improvement notice, and a letter to the Traffic Commissioner I'd rather not have had to write.

The opt-out your HR team knows about comes from the Working Time Regulations 1998. That legislation covers most workers. But HGV drivers doing work governed by EU drivers' hours rules aren't covered by the 1998 Regulations — they're covered by the Road Transport (Working Time) Regulations 2005 instead. And those Regulations have no opt-out. None. The provision that used to allow one was revoked in 2012.

Two rulebooks, and most tachograph analysis only checks one

This is the confusion that catches operators every year. Tachograph analysis software checks EU hours compliance under Regulation (EC) 561/2006. That's driving time, break rules, daily rest, weekly rest. Important, yes. But it doesn't check working time. And working time is broader than driving time — it's regulated separately, and the penalties for getting it wrong come through the same Traffic Commissioner route.

The Road Transport (Working Time) Regulations 2005 cover the total working period: driving, loading and unloading, assisting passengers, cleaning, maintenance, any other work you're directing the driver to do. Waiting time at a loading bay where the driver has a specific scheduled start counts too. Periods of availability — time waiting where the duration was known in advance — can be excluded, but only if the driver genuinely knew the duration from the start. Your normal depot waiting time usually doesn't qualify for that exclusion.

So a driver who does 4.5 hours of driving, stops for 45 minutes, drives another 4.5 hours, then spends two hours on loading duties has a clean EU hours record. But they've also put in 11 hours of working time under the 2005 Regulations. Two separate calculations, two separate instruments, and one of them isn't being checked by the software most operators rely on.

The limits under the 2005 Regulations

Regulation 4 sets two limits.

First, an absolute cap. Working time must not exceed 60 hours in any single week (reg 4(1)). No agreement changes this. No employer instruction overrides it. Sixty hours per week is the hard ceiling.

Second — and this is the one that actually catches most operators — over any reference period, average weekly working time must not exceed 48 hours (reg 4(2)). You calculate this by dividing total working time across the reference period by the number of weeks in that period. Come out above 48 on average and your driver has breached the limit, even if they never once exceeded 60 hours in a single week.

The default reference period is 17 weeks. Where no collective or workforce agreement specifies otherwise, the Regulations fix it to calendar periods: 1 December to 1 April, 1 April to 1 August, and 1 August to 1 December. Those are fixed, not rolling. A collective agreement can extend the period to up to 26 weeks for objective or technical reasons — but that's an agreement, not a unilateral management decision, and it requires proper collective or workforce agreement procedures.

And — back to the opt-out question — there isn't one. Regulation 3(4)(a), which had provided for an individual opt-out, was revoked in 2012. That's not a minor qualification or a grey area. You cannot ask a professional HGV driver subject to these Regulations to sign away their rights to the 48-hour average, and any agreement purporting to do so has no legal effect.

Night work: a separate 10-hour cap, and a smaller window than you think

Regulation 9 adds a further limit for night work. A mobile worker who performs night work must not work more than 10 hours in any 24-hour period (reg 9(1)).

Under the 2005 Regulations, "night time" for goods vehicles runs from midnight to 4 a.m. That's the definition in regulation 2. Four hours. If any part of a driver's shift falls within that window, they've performed night work for the purposes of the Regulation — and the 10-hour-per-24-hours cap applies to the whole day, not just the four-hour window.

There's a provision allowing the 10-hour limit to be extended by collective or workforce agreement, for objective or technical reasons. But again, that requires a proper agreement — not a unilateral employer notice or an individual contract clause.

Trunk operations are the obvious risk. A driver starting at 10 p.m., arriving at a reload point at 2 a.m., waiting an hour for loading, and completing their run home by 6 a.m. has worked during the midnight-to-4 a.m. window. Without proper shift records and a working time calculation that covers the full 24 hours around that window, the breach won't appear on a tachograph printout.

What DVSA actually looks for

From my Traffic Examiner visit and from talking to operators who've had the same experience: they check three things.

First, do you have a working time policy? Not a drivers' hours policy — a working time policy, separate, that correctly sets out the limits under the 2005 Regulations. It must not say the 48-hour limit is subject to an opt-out. If it does, you've already failed.

Second, are you actually analysing and recording working time, separately from EU hours? If your tachograph analysis reports only driving time infringements, you're not meeting this standard. They want to see that someone is calculating average working time across the reference period and reviewing it.

Third, have drivers been briefed? A policy document in a filing cabinet isn't enough. There should be a briefing record, signed and dated by each driver, confirming they've been told about the working time rules that apply to them. Not just drivers' hours — the working time rules specifically.

We had a policy. It said the wrong thing. We had no separate analysis. We had no working time briefing records. The Traffic Examiner was, I'd say, fairly patient about it.

Running the calculation from tachograph data

If you're already doing 28-day tachograph downloads, most of the raw data you need is already there. The vehicle unit and driver card record activity modes: drive, other work, availability, rest. Working time under the 2005 Regulations is drive time plus other-work time. Availability — where the driver was waiting and the duration was known in advance — is excluded. Rest is excluded.

From a standard tachograph dataset, add drive time and other-work time for each week. Then average it across the reference period. Flag anything above 48. For night workers, check each day where the driver worked between midnight and 4 a.m. and confirm total working time that day was under 10 hours.

The complication is mixed operations. If a driver sometimes does GB domestic work that's exempt from EU hours, those shifts won't appear on the tachograph in the standard EU mode. You need a separate record for those days — a manual working time record showing shift start, shift end, break periods, and total working time. Without it, you can't produce the full working time calculation if DVSA asks.

Drivers doing significant manual work — loading, securing, paperwork — that isn't captured on the tachograph need that in the working time record too. The tachograph only captures what the driver actively records. If your drivers are spending time on manual tasks between runs and not pressing the 'work' button, you're under-counting their working time.

Record retention and what to keep

The 2005 Regulations don't prescribe a specific retention period for working time records. But the Working Time Directive at EU level required two years. And because many operators rely on tachograph data as their working time record, the 24-month tachograph retention rule becomes the baseline here too — specifically, 24 months applies where tacho data is the only source of working time records.

What should be on the record: driver name, reference period, weekly working time for each week in the period, and the calculated average. For night workers, daily records showing total working time on days where midnight to 4 a.m. was worked.

Three things I do differently now

I have a separate working time policy that explicitly states there is no opt-out available for HGV drivers covered by the 2005 Regulations. It references the Regulations by name. It's signed, filed, and in the driver handbook.

Our tachograph analysis generates a working time output alongside the EU hours analysis — weekly working time per driver, averaged across the reference period. Anything above 44 hours per week average gets flagged as a management trigger before it becomes a breach.

The reference period start dates are on the fleet calendar. December, April, August. They're fixed dates, they don't change, and missing the period end means you can't produce the calculation if DVSA comes calling.

It took one uncomfortable Traffic Examiner visit to build all of that. Hopefully this means you don't need the same introduction.

WTDHGV ComplianceDriver Managementworking time

Run a fleet that has to keep DVSA happy?

FleetPad replaces walkaround paperwork, defect logs, and PMI records with one system the transport manager actually reads.