Fleet maintenance records: the PMI interval rule that catches out 3 in 4 fleets
The maintenance planner is the first document a TC opens at audit. Three out of four planners I've seen were out of date, missing vehicles, or printed that morning. Here's the rule I keep to.

The first time a vehicle missed its PMI on my watch, it was because the operations manager said the truck was too busy to come off the road. The delivery schedule was tight, the customer was important, and the inspection could wait a week. I agreed. The inspection slipped from week 6 to week 7. Then it slipped to week 8. Then the truck got pulled at a DVSA check site and the officer asked to see the maintenance records. The last inspection was 9 weeks old against a 6 week declared interval on the O-licence. That gap cost us a written warning from the Traffic Commissioner and a very uncomfortable conversation with the director about why a scheduled inspection did not happen on schedule.
Every fleet that has ever grown beyond four or five vehicles has had this exact conversation. The inspection schedule says one thing. The operational reality says another. The gap between the two is where compliance failures happen, and it is almost always invisible until DVSA or the Traffic Commissioner asks to see the records.
What a PMI actually is
A Preventive Maintenance Inspection is the scheduled safety inspection carried out by a qualified fitter or approved workshop at regular intervals. It sits between the daily walkaround check done by the driver before every shift and the annual test done by DVSA at an Authorised Testing Facility. The PMI is where the serious defects get found, the ones a driver would never spot during a walkaround because they require a pit, a ramp, or a brake roller to detect.
A typical PMI covers brake performance, suspension, steering, tyres, wheel fixings, chassis condition, lighting, exhaust, fluid levels, and any vehicle-specific items like tail lift operation or refrigeration units. The inspection should follow a written checklist, and the completed checklist becomes part of the vehicle's maintenance record. If a defect is found during the PMI, it should be repaired before the vehicle goes back on the road or, if the defect is not safety-critical, deferred with a written note and a date for repair. That deferral needs to actually be followed up. A deferred defect with no follow-up date is just a forgotten defect.
How to set PMI intervals
The DVSA Guide to Maintaining Roadworthiness does not prescribe a single fixed interval for PMIs. It says the interval should be determined by the operator based on the type of operation, the age and condition of the vehicles, the mileage covered, and the environment they work in. In practice, most O-licence holders declare an interval of between 6 and 13 weeks when they apply for or vary their licence.
Six weeks is the standard for high-mileage HGVs doing long-haul or multi-drop work. This is what most Traffic Commissioners expect to see on a standard national licence with vehicles covering 2,000 miles a week or more. Eight weeks is common for medium-mileage fleets doing regional work. Anything beyond 10 weeks needs a strong justification, and that justification usually involves newer vehicles, lower mileage, and a demonstrably good maintenance track record.
The interval you declare on the O-licence is a promise. If you declare 6 weeks and your records show inspections at 6, 7, 8, 6, 9, 7 weeks, the Traffic Commissioner does not see a fleet that was mostly on time. They see a fleet that breached its declared interval four times. The declared interval is the maximum gap, not the average. Every inspection that exceeds it is an undertaking breach.
I ran my fleet on a 6 week interval and scheduled the inspections for 5 weeks and 3 days. That buffer of 4 days gave enough room for the truck to come back from a delivery and reach the workshop without breaching the declared interval. If you schedule at exactly 6 weeks you have zero margin, and the first delayed delivery or workshop backlog puts you over.
The maintenance planner
The maintenance planner is a forward-looking document, usually a single page or spreadsheet, showing every vehicle and trailer in the fleet with their scheduled PMI dates for the next 6 to 12 months. This is the first document the Traffic Commissioner asks for during an O-licence audit, and it is the one that tells them the most in the shortest time.
A good maintenance planner tells the TC that you know what is due, when, and that you are actively managing the schedule. A bad one tells them you printed it this morning. The TC can tell the difference. A planner with neat, evenly spaced dates and no history of updates looks manufactured. A planner with handwritten adjustments, crossed-out dates where a vehicle came in early because of a defect, and notes in the margins about workshop availability looks real. Because it is.
If your planner is a spreadsheet, make sure it has a last-updated date and that the date is recent. If it is a wall chart, make sure it is visible, current, and shows actual inspection dates alongside planned dates. If you use fleet management software, make sure you can produce a printout of the planner in under a minute, because that is roughly how long the TC will wait before forming an opinion about your record-keeping.
What goes wrong
I have seen the same failures repeated across every fleet I have worked with. They are not complicated. They are just persistent.
Inspections that slip and nobody notices. The schedule says 6 weeks. The truck is out on a contract. Week 7 passes. Week 8 passes. Nobody flagged it because the planner was not actively monitored, or the planner was monitored but the operations team overrode the recall because the customer came first. By the time the truck comes in, the gap is on record and cannot be undone.
Incomplete inspection sheets. The fitter checks 40 items on a 50 item checklist and signs the bottom. Nobody reads the checklist to see that 10 items are blank. During an audit, the Traffic Commissioner reads the checklist. A partially completed inspection is treated as a partially completed inspection, not as a pass. Blank items suggest either the items were not checked or the checklist is not being taken seriously. Neither is a good look.
Defects found and not followed up. The PMI identifies a worn brake pad. The fitter writes it on the sheet. The pad is not replaced because the parts are not in stock. The vehicle goes back on the road with a note saying the pad will be replaced next week. Next week comes and goes. The note is still on the inspection sheet. The pad is still worn. At the next PMI, the same defect appears. This is the pattern that turns a minor maintenance issue into a compliance failure, because it shows the system is not working.
No brake performance data. The Guide to Maintaining Roadworthiness says brake performance should be monitored and recorded at each PMI. This means roller brake test data with actual efficiency percentages for each axle. Many workshops still do PMIs without a brake roller and rely on a visual inspection of pads, discs, and drums. That is better than nothing, but during an audit the TC will ask for brake test data and if you do not have it, they will note the gap. I started insisting on roller brake data at every PMI after one of our vehicles failed its annual test on brakes despite having a clean PMI sheet from three weeks earlier. The PMI said the brakes were fine. The roller said they were at 38%. Both could not be right.
Making maintenance records audit-ready
The records the Traffic Commissioner asks for during an audit are not exotic. They are the records you should already have if your maintenance system is working:
- The maintenance planner, forward-looking, with actual inspection dates filled in as they happen.
- Completed PMI inspection sheets for every vehicle and trailer, for the period requested (usually the last 12 to 15 months).
- Brake performance data from roller tests at each PMI.
- A record of defects found at PMI and the date they were rectified.
- Driver walkaround defect reports and how they were resolved.
- Annual test certificates and any Presentation Result Summaries from failed tests.
If you can produce all of this for any vehicle in your fleet within five minutes, you are audit-ready. If it takes you an afternoon of searching through filing cabinets and calling the workshop for missing paperwork, you are not. The vehicle check and defect system in FleetPad was designed around this exact scenario, giving the transport manager a complete vehicle history that can be exported in seconds. But the tool only works if the data is going in. A digital system with missing inspections is no better than a paper system with missing inspections.
Frequently asked questions
What PMI interval should I declare on my O-licence?
The honest answer is the shortest interval you can reliably maintain without breaching it. If you declare 6 weeks and regularly hit 7 or 8, you are better off declaring 8 and actually meeting it. A fleet that declares 8 weeks and hits 8 every time looks more compliant than a fleet that declares 6 and hits it half the time. I ran on 6 weeks because my vehicles were doing high mileage and I wanted the brakes checked frequently, but I scheduled internally at 5 weeks and 3 days to give myself a buffer.
Can I change my declared PMI interval?
Yes, by varying your O-licence. You apply to the traffic area office and explain why you want to change. If you are extending the interval, say from 6 to 8 weeks, you need to justify it with evidence that the vehicles can safely go longer between inspections. If you are shortening it, the TC will generally approve without difficulty because shorter intervals are more cautious. The application takes a few weeks to process.
Does my workshop need to be approved by DVSA to carry out PMIs?
Not formally, no. PMIs can be carried out by any competent person or workshop. However, the standard of the inspection and the qualifications of the person doing it will be scrutinised if the records are ever audited. Using a workshop with DVSA Authorised Testing Facility status, or at minimum IRTEC accreditation for the fitters, adds credibility to the records. A PMI carried out by the owner's mate in a barn with no brake roller will not inspire confidence in a Traffic Commissioner.
How long should I keep maintenance records?
DVSA recommends keeping records for at least 15 months, which covers the period the Traffic Commissioner will typically request. In practice I kept everything for three years because records are small, storage is cheap, and being able to show a long-term maintenance history is a real advantage during an audit. If you ever need to demonstrate continuous compliance over time, three years of clean records is far more persuasive than the minimum 15 months.
What happens if I miss a PMI entirely?
It depends on how it comes to light. If DVSA finds a missed PMI during an audit, it is treated as a breach of your O-licence undertaking. One missed inspection on an otherwise clean record will probably result in a warning. Multiple missed inspections, or a missed inspection that coincides with a vehicle defect or accident, could trigger a call-up to the Traffic Commissioner. The worst outcome I have seen from a single missed PMI was a requirement to commission an independent audit of the entire fleet at the operator's expense. That cost more than a year of on-time inspections would have.
Fleet maintenance is not the exciting part of running a transport operation. It is the part that keeps the operation running. The fleets that get it right are not the ones with the fanciest workshops or the most expensive software. They are the ones where somebody, usually the transport manager, looks at the maintenance planner every Monday morning and makes sure nothing has slipped. That weekly habit is worth more than any system.